Table of Contents
Little Shop of Horrors has actually been through lots of versions, from the initial 1960 Roger Corman scary movie to the 1982 phase musical to Frank Oz’s 1986 movie adjustment of that musical. Now it might end up back on screens once again, as Love, Simon director and Arrowverse writer-producer Greg Berlanti is out to bring the musical back to the big screen.
Oz’s 1986 film has a ideal cast, with Rick Moranis as the unpopular floral designer Seymour Krelborn; Ellen Greene as Audrey, the shy colleague he has a crush on; Steve Martin as Audrey’s vicious dental expert partner, Orin Scrivello; and Levi Stubbs as the voice of the alien plant Audrey II, who turns Seymour’s fortunes around. This has actually made the casting reports swirling around the brand-new movie especially amazing.
Billy Porter is the just validated cast member as the brand-new Audrey II, however Taron Egerton and Scarlett Johansson are reported to be circling around the lead functions, and Chris Evans has actually been reported as being in talks for the function of Orin. Porter is a hard casting option to beat, the Polygon personnel have actually banded together to put forth our perfect choices for the functions.
Tasha Robinson, film/TV editor
Seymour: Brie Larson
Audrey: Tom Holland
Audrey II: Janelle Monáe
Orin: Charlize Theron
Bonus offer casting: Michael Stuhlbarg as store owner Mr. Mushnik
Let’s admit it, the social characteristics of Little Shop of Horrors are quite regressive: useless geek starves after stunning dumb girl, who’s controlled by a psychopath however covertly wishes to be with the useless geek. In the 1960 s version, Seymour was played as grossly useless, and in the 1980 s version, he’s sweetly useless with a big side order of “comical stereotype.” Neither film takes him all that seriously as a character. It ‘d be hard to put this exact same story on the screen today without it feeling like an incel stalker dream where an uncomfortable guy finds out that simply ceaselessly hanging around the woman of his dreams (oh, and feeding her partner to a monster-plant) is sufficient to make her see he’s much better for her than anybody else. Let’s mess with those characteristics! The Frank Oz version of this film is simply about ideal, so rather of affecting it severely, let’s do something drastically various!
We understand from the MCU Spider-Man motion pictures that Tom Holland can do sweet vulnerability. Let’s have him as the doe-eyed love interest, under the thumb of unflinching, aggressive dental expert Charlize Theron, while uncomfortable floral designer Brie Larson wishes for him. And after that Brie gets some lessons in ferocity from Janelle Monáe, who has the big, positive voice and outsized character to play Audrey II, and some experience at inhuman/alien singing functions to boot. Yeah, the gender-swap here may develop some bothersome and unusual relationship characteristics, however the initial is simply as unusual and bothersome, so why not press the limits of what this setup can do?
Karen Han, home entertainment press reporter
Seymour: Paul Dano
Audrey: Park So-dam
Audrey II: Will Smith
Orin: Patrick Wilson
I like Taron Egerton, however casting him as Seymour is a criminal offense. As much as I enjoyed Jake Gyllenhaal’s efficiency as Seymour at Encores!, I simply can’t excuse it. Traditionally hot Seymour is incorrect! Paul Dano, who is hot, however in a various classification. We likewise understand that he can sing from his efficiency in Love & Grace. We understand Park So-dam can bring a tune from Parasite’s renowned “Jessica, Just Kid” jingle, and she’s stated she began acting due to the fact thatshe wanted to be in musicals Park likewise has extremely earnest features, which I believe is ideal for Audrey. When It Comes To Audrey II, concealing somebody as identifiable as Will Smith behind a plant would be a enjoyable turnaround. Plus, Smith simply played the Genie in Disney’s live-action Aladdin, so we understand he has the variety. Patrick Wilson isn’t in the exact same age bracket as Paul Dano and Park So-dam, however he’s so stunning, and such an extraordinary vocalist, that I believe carrying all of that into a wicked dental expert would be a lot of enjoyable.
Emily Heller, commerce author
Seymour: Kristen Stewart
Audrey: Keke Palmer
Audrey II: Nic Cage
Orin: Taran Killam
Bonus offer casting: Tony Shalhoub as Mr. Mushnik
I saw Taran Killam play Orin in the 2015 Encores! Little Shop, and he definitely eliminated it. Killam manages manic creepy-sexy much better than anybody, and his efficiency is worthy of a larger spotlight. When it comes to the main love of Audrey and Seymour, there’s absolutely nothing queerer than squashing on your friend and disliking her dreadful partner. I desire a lesbian Seymour and bisexual Audrey, dammit! We understand Kristen Stewart can sing (she played Joan Jett in The Runaways), and like Seymour, she’s a substantial geek. Keke Palmer’s character in Hustlers has an earnest, infectiously lovely energy that’s vital for Audrey.
Lastly, Nic Cage is a stunning force of turmoil. Enough stated.
Matt Patches, senior home entertainment editor
Seymour: Demi Adejuyigbe
Audrey: Karen Gillan
Audrey II: RuPaul
Orin: Rami Malek
Bonus offer casting: Ashleigh Murray, Hayley Law, and Asha Bromfield as Crystal, Ronnette, and Chiffon
Each time Demi Adejuyigbe goes viral with a brand-new Phony Film Tune, “Earth, Wind, and Fire Day” homage, or 10-second musical joke, I question why Hollywood has yet to cast him in a significant starvehicle A musical about a meek amateur botanist who sings his feels appears suitable. For Audrey, I’m truly searching for variety, somebody who can do the flighty, bubblegum-popping funny, then totally flooring us with “Someplace That’s Green” and “All of a sudden Seymour.” I’ll indicate Gillan on her short-term comedy Selfie as proof I’m on the money here. (Watch her perform Sia’s “Chandelier” in one of the show’s more earnest minutes.) I’m completing the cast with a Mean Green Mother Ru, an Oscar-winner who appears extremely mindful of Performing Cool, and most likely the most unforgettable woman-group threesome from current memory: Josie and the Pussycats from Riverdale.
Chris Plante, editor-in- chief
Seymour: Randall Park
Audrey II: Donald Glover
Orin: Lakeith Stanfield
Bonus offer casting: Judd Hirsch as Mr. Mushnik
Park is my preferred “geek” stock gamer. He’s cornered the market on awkwardly amusing, and more just recently, he showed he can conjure old-school Hollywood chemistry. The Little Shop script utilizes Audrey to highlight the deceptions of the American dream, and Mitski has the brochure and variety to do simply that. Donald Glover is the ideal mix of comic and singer, however I acknowledge it would be a waste for him to be concealed behind a puppet. When it comes to Orin, it’s a almost difficult function to cast. The star needs to be a hip-thrusting charmer, a masochistic abuser, and a pleasant Catskills comic, frequently in the exact same line of discussion. Much better than any star working today, Lakeith Stanfield can do more with less. And when it comes to Judd Hirsch, he’s Judd Hirsch. How has he not played Mr. Mushnik a million times? Have y’ all even viewed Self-reliance Day?
Ryan Gilliam, news author
Seymour: Timothée Chalamet
Audrey: Florence Pugh
Audrey II: Will Smith
Orin: Daniel Craig
Benefit Casting: Don Johnson as Mr. Mushnik
If you have actually been staying up to date with this list up until now, you might believe that I simply took Will Smith from Karen Han. You ‘d be. That’s due to the fact that he’s ideal. He’s the only appropriate response, and I will hear no arguments.
When it comes to my initial casting, I took motivation from the very best film of 2019 for my leads: LittleWomen Timothée Chalamet has actually done generally whatever in his brief profession, from charming dope in Little Women to dismal asshole in Girl Bird to heartbreaker in Call Me By Your Name. Let me see him play definitely dreadful however well-meaning Seymour. I understand he can do it, and I ‘d simply like to see him in glasses.
Florence Pugh is ideal, and I’ll enjoy her do anything. Most notably, I’ll enjoy her sing. Did you understand she when had a YouTube channel filled with acoustic covers? (Who didn’t in high school?) They’re great, therefore is Florence Pugh.
Daniel Craig’s turn as unhinged dynamites specialist Joe Bang in Logan Lucky is simply wonderful things. I ‘d like to see him turn that approximately 11 and handle the violent, masochistic, singing dental expert Orin.
Why should Don Johnson be Mr. Mushnik? Since Don Johnson is a limitless well of charm. When Mr. Mushnik gets consumed by Audrey II, I live to see the face he makes.
Simone de Rochefort, senior video manufacturer
Seymour: Cillian Murphy
Audrey: Dita Von Teese
Audrey II: Eminem
Orin: Johnny Depp
Prior to you go nuts, the style of this casting is “individuals I believed were hot in 2005,” which is when I first saw Cillian Murphy carry out as Scarecrow in Batman Starts. I spitballed from there, which indicates this casting goes to some unusual goth locations, however I dedicated to it, and I will not alter.
I have not seen Little Shop of Horrors considering that I was a kid, however I have actually seen Cillian Murphy in a lot of seasons of Peaky Blinders. Despite the fact that he’s an adult male in his 40 s, he’s capable of carrying heavenly waifishness, however likewise of devoting murder– both crucial for the clingy however weak-willed Seymour. Playing Seymour would still enable him to bend his variety, as the function is much more understanding and less up its own ass than Peaky Blinders, which just lets him reveal the feelings of “I dislike others,” and “I dislike myself.”
Sadly, to remain on style, we need to bring Johnny Depp into the mix. Since I’m deeply over him as a individual, he gets the jerk function of Orin. I am casting Dita Von Teese as Audrey due to the fact that I simply discovered she can arrange of sing, and she would bring a Unusual Sexual Energy to the function that I am deeply here for.
As my coup de grâce (specified by the Oxford Dictionary as “a final blow or shot offered to eliminate a injured individual or animal,” which I will be getting from our home entertainment editor after I finish this casting roundup), we merely need to cast Eminem as Audrey II. The thinking is as follows:
When I thought about the possibility of Audrey II rapping in Eminem’s nasal voice I instantly began laughing,
I hope this assists the manufacturers of Little Shop of Horrors in their casting search. I believe my concepts are advanced, maybe frighteningly so, and I eagerly anticipate keeping in mind the occasions of the musical when I see this movie in theaters.
Additionally, follow the thinking of Morgan M. Page and Casey Plett and make it the trans retelling it is implied to be!